This yarn has great feel: soft, bouncy. I made fingerless gloves that were gifted, so I can't say how it wears. It knitted up beautifully, and was fun to handle. No pilling, shedding, or splitting while working with it. So soft!
Made a shawl from this and loved working with it. Since, I've dragged the shawl all over, packed it my my carry-on bag, and generally given it vigorous use. The yarn has held up beautifully - no pilling. I loved it and ordered more. It will shed some small halo on dark clothes, but I love the softness and hand and think it's a small amount.
Madeline Tosh has such wonderful rich color. I haven't knitted my Vintage yet, but the other Tosh yarns I've used have been lovely to knit with, made a beautiful product, and stood up to wear w/o pilling.